Tuesday, March 24, 2015

Language Blog Post

Part 1:
This week I was in a 15 minute conversation where I was not allowed to speak. This conversation was harder than expected because I am a person who is very verbal, enthusiastic and bold about expressing my thoughts. Having said all this, these 15 minutes felt like a never ending conversation for me. I chose to have my conversation with my parents and little sister—without the speaking part.  When I began trying to express my thoughts through physical expressions, my parents seemed lost and very confused, when my father finally laughed at me saying, “it was awkward because we couldn’t communicate verbally, which comes natural to us”. My little sister was getting very confused she wanted to know why I couldn’t just talk to her instead of acting out my thoughts. When I was using gestures to communicate with my sister it brought me to the feeling of when she was a baby. I had to use so many hand gestures and movements to connect with her because that was her “language”. I felt like I was a baby trying to communicate with a parent. After an extensive five minutes, my parents eventually altered their way of communicating with me; using hand gestures and speaking slowly (as if I really did speak another language). I feel that if we represented two different cultures meeting for the first time that I would have had the advantage in communicating complex ideas. I think that the speaking culture would have a “snobby” and maybe even irritated attitude towards the culture that doesn’t use language because they know what they are trying to communicate but all they are getting in response would be antics. Babies and toddlers, everywhere, have difficulty communicating with spoken language and it affects adults and older children that do interact with them.  As adults we try to interact with babies by overly expressing our emotions and speaking slowly and loudly to convey our feelings and words. In the experiment, this is how my parents were trying to convey their thoughts to me while I couldn’t speak. I definitely felt like a baby.
Part 2:
In the second half of the experiment, I engaged in another 15 minute conversation, however this time without any physical signals, vocal intonation or body/facial movements. I could not last the entire 15 minutes this time. This experiment was very difficult for me because I naturally use a lot of body and facial expressions to communicate often. Every two minutes I realized I would raise and lower my voice or smile.  I carried on this conversation with my parents. My mother said, “I lost all track of what we were talking about because of your monotonous tone…it was really boring...sorry”. This experiment “speaks” for itself .  Signs are so important to our language and our ability to communicate effectively. These “non-speech language techniques” play a large role in our communication on so many levels; it’s how we read others body language and how we are able to adapt to others emotions and antics while they speak. It pushes our language farther than just words, its feelings, passions, and insights.  There are many people who do, however have difficulty reading body language. I think it might be the way they grew up—maybe they weren’t social or brought up in a manner to think much of body language. I think an environmental condition that might have a benefit to not reading body language would be in the coldest places on Earth; where no one would want to stand in the freezing cold to move their faces or open their arms while speaking, allowing the cold to take hold of them.
Overall, I felt that this experiment relates to the old saying, “Actions speak louder than words”

3 comments:

  1. I found it interesting that your parents became so frustrated in communicating with you in part 1 that they began to use hand gestures and started to speak slower to you in hopes that that might help the process of conversation. It almost seemed liked they were treating you as if you were hearing impaired. I enjoyed reading about your family and this language experiment. Good job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very good discussion on your Part A experiences and I like your comparison with the way we talk to children. Good analogy, and if you think about how people tend to talk to non-native speakers or those who have speech difficulties due to physical disbilities, we tend to speak more slowly and loudly with them, just we would children. Why do we do that? Keep in mind, that this parent/child analogy also reflects two different intellects, with the "smarter" person speaking in a condescending manner to the "less smart" person, and indeed we seem to associate speech ability with intelligence. Why do we make this connection?

    Good description of your Part B experiment. The responses of the partners is always the most interesting part of this experiment.

    Yes, non-spoken language contributes meaning and clarification, but it also allows people to verify what you are saying, kind of like a lie-detector. If your body language doesn't match the words you are saying, this tells the person that you aren't telling the truth and perhaps can't be trusted. Why would this be beneficial in an adaptive sense?

    There is natural variation in all of our abilities to read body language, just as with any trait, but there are specific groups that have significant impairment in reading body language, such as those in the autism spectrum and also (to a certain degree) those who are blind.

    The arctic is a place where you wouldn't want to use body language but that doesn't mean you shouldn't try to read it. Can you think of a situation where body language might mislead you? Do all cultures use the same system of body language?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice use of puns in part 2 :^)
    I was someone who found part 2 to be less challenging than the first part and didn't quite get the results others, like yourself, have found. I don't really use many hand gestures and such when talking which is why I think it was much easier for myself, because you are a person who uses a lot of body language in speaking. It's really interesting to see how much body language can change a conversation as well. Nice post, well done!

    ReplyDelete